U.S. Securities and Exchange Commissionregulator
DevelopingRegulation

SEC Commissioner Peirce says investors need no exemption for permissionless DeFi

CryptoSlate reports that Hester Peirce says investors need no exemption for permissionless smart contracts; it calls the statement her individual view and 'truly decentralized' undefined.

Why it matters

CryptoSlate said no unified federal decentralization test exists and that the point at which a software provider resembles a regulated intermediary remains unresolved. The SEC and CFTC actions operate under different statutes and carry different legal effects.

Key facts

CryptoSlate reported that Hester Peirce said investors need no exemption to use permissionless smart contracts for peer-to-peer trading.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said Peirce's statement expressed her individual view and that a binding SEC definition would require Commission action.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate described the SEC's Sept. 17 tokenized-securities order as an order of the Commission.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said a CFTC staff statement permits more promotion by passive software providers, subject to custody and routing limits.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said the SEC order and CFTC staff statement leave 'truly decentralized' undefined and address custody, access, software parameters, fees, recommendations, routing and execution.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said relief for tokenized-stock venues depends on who controls access, fees, parameters and trading pauses.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said the SEC and CFTC actions operate under different statutes and carry different legal effects.

Reported by CryptoSlate

CryptoSlate said a unified federal decentralization test remains absent and left unresolved how much control a software provider can retain before beginning to resemble a regulated intermediary.

Reported by CryptoSlate

What happened

CryptoSlate reported that SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce said on Sept. 17 that investors do not require an exemption to trade peer to peer through permissionless smart contracts. Her statement set out her individual view, and a binding SEC definition would require Commission action. CryptoSlate said the SEC's Sept. 17 tokenized-securities order and a separate CFTC staff statement did not define 'truly decentralized' and instead addressed custody, access, software parameters, fees, recommendations, routing and execution. CryptoSlate said relief for tokenized-stock venues depends on who controls access, fees, parameters and trading pauses. It also said the CFTC staff statement permits more promotion by passive software providers, subject to custody and routing limits. CryptoSlate said it remained unresolved how much control a software provider can retain before beginning to resemble a regulated intermediary.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by CryptoSlate

    Why truly decentralized DeFi needs no legal exemption according to SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce

    CryptoSlate

  2. Official statement

    Peirce stated her view on permissionless DeFi

    CryptoSlate said Peirce said on Sept. 17 that investors need no exemption to use permissionless smart contracts for peer-to-peer trading and identified the statement as her individual view.

    CryptoSlate

  3. Official statement

    SEC issued tokenized-securities order

    CryptoSlate described the Sept. 17 action as an order of the Commission.

    CryptoSlate

  4. Official statement

    CFTC staff addressed passive software providers

    CryptoSlate said a CFTC staff statement permits more promotion by passive software providers, subject to custody and routing limits.

    CryptoSlate

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
Why truly decentralized DeFi needs no legal exemption according to SEC Commissioner Hester PeirceOriginal