Senate Blocks CLARITY Act 50-49 as SEC Staff Sets Buyback Rules and Custody Proposal
The Senate voted 50-49 against cloture on the CLARITY Act, after which SEC staff cleared token buybacks on functional networks and the agency proposed custody rules for advisers and funds.
Why it matters
Congress has not set market-structure rules, so the burden of clarifying token status and custody moved to SEC and CFTC staff guidance and rulemaking that carries no legal force and can be reversed. Institutions still lack a settled qualified-custodian path, which Decrypt ties directly to advisers' hesitation to offer digital-asset strategies.
Key facts
The Senate voted 49 in favour and 50 against invoking cloture on H.R. 3633, the CLARITY Act, on Sept. 15, with one senator not voting.
Reported by Crypto.News
The cloture motion needed 60 votes, three-fifths of the Senate, to begin debate.
60 votesReported by Crypto.News
Crypto.News reported the same vote as 50-49 against cloture and said the result fell 10 votes short of the 60 required.
50 votesDisputed figureReported by Crypto.News
SEC Chair Paul Atkins said the SEC will act with or without legislation.
Reported by CoinGape
The SEC's Division of Corporation Finance published FAQs saying that on a functional crypto system an issuer's announcement of a non-security crypto asset buyback program would not constitute a promise to undertake essential managerial efforts under the Howey test.
Reported by Unchained
The same FAQs said a buyback announcement on a network that is not yet functional could count as a promise if the issuer presents it as creating yield or return for token holders.
Reported by Unchained
Unchained reported the division revised its crypto FAQ on Sept. 28, three days after first publication, adding the words and has no central party to the buyback answer.
Reported by Unchained
What happened
The Senate voted 50-49 against invoking cloture on H.R. 3633, the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, on Sept. 15, leaving the motion 11 votes short of the three-fifths threshold needed to begin debate. Crypto.News reported the vote as 50-49 against cloture and noted it fell 10 votes short of the 60 needed; Crypto.News and BTC-ECHO describe it as 49 in favour against 50 against, with BTC-ECHO noting the 60-vote threshold was missed. CoinDesk, citing interviews with more than a dozen industry participants and legislative aides, attributed the failure to a piecemeal Senate version, the White House complicating negotiations, Democrats rejecting an ethics deal, and time running out ahead of the midterm election. With Congress stalled, SEC Chair Paul Atkins said the agency will act under existing authority, and the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance published FAQs on Sept. 25 stating that on a functional crypto system a token buyback announcement would not by itself be a promise of essential managerial efforts under the Howey test, while warning that on networks that are not yet functional the same announcement could cross the line if presented as yield for holders. Three days later Unchained reported the division revised the answer on Sept. 28 to add the condition that the system must also have no central party, and Decrypt noted attorney Gabriel Shapiro called the original guidance a loophole that carries no legal force. On Oct. 1 the SEC proposed rules that would permit self-custody under some conditions and let state trust companies act as qualified custodians for registered advisers and regulated funds, which Decrypt grouped with the agency's innovation exemption and Regulation Crypto Assets. Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan, writing Sept. 30, said the failure handed crypto better rules faster and identified stablecoin platforms such as Coinbase, which kept balance rewards the bill would have restricted with penalties up to $5 million per violation. Michael Saylor urged the industry to use existing paths and target 50 million users before returning to Congress.
How the story developed
- Update
Senate fails to invoke cloture on H.R. 3633
Roll call showed 49 for, 50 against, one not voting, on a procedural motion requiring60 votes to begin debate.
- Official statement
Atkins says SEC will act under existing authority
SEC Chair Paul Atkins said with or without legislation, we will act, after thanking those who worked on the CLARITY Act.
- Update
CFTC sends crypto market rulemaking to White House review
Cointelegraph's related reporting and the Crypto.News account record the CFTC sending crypto market rulemaking to White House review on Sept. 17.
- First report
First report by Crypto.News
CLARITY Act failure could rebuild crypto middlemen: GenLayer CEO
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by BTC-ECHO
Krypto-News: Fed erhöht Zinsen – Clarity Act scheitert
- Official statement
SEC Division of Corporation Finance publishes buyback FAQs
Staff said a buyback announcement on a functional system would not be a promise of essential managerial efforts, while flagging yield pitches on unfinished networks.
- Mainstream pickup
Picked up by mainstream media (Finance Magnates Crypto)
DeFi Was Never Going to Get Its Clarity from US Congress
- Correction
Correction published by Crypto.News
SEC staff clarifies when staking tokens may avoid securities rules
- Update
Shapiro calls the buyback FAQ a loophole
Gabriel Shapiro, a corporate securities attorney at MetaLeX Labs and former general counsel at Delphi, said the guidance is staff guidance without legal force that a future SEC could reverse.
- Official statement
Official statement from Bitcoin.com News
Jamaican Lawmakers Debate New Law to Regulate Crypto Firms
- Official statement
SEC proposes crypto custody framework for advisers and funds
The proposal would permit self-custody under certain conditions, allow state trust companies to serve as custodians, and update audit and broker-dealer custodial rules under the Advisers Act and Investment Company Act.
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 18 Sept 2026, 16:17 UTC: Crypto.News — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 20 Sept 2026, 02:00 UTC: BTC-ECHO — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
- 25 Sept 2026, 09:25 UTC: Finance Magnates Crypto, Mainstream media — 3 independent sources, 6 reports
- 25 Sept 2026, 15:33 UTC: CoinGape — 4 independent sources, 7 reports
- 25 Sept 2026, 19:06 UTC: Crypto News (CryptoNews.net) — 5 independent sources, 8 reports
- 25 Sept 2026, 19:30 UTC: Crypto News Flash — 6 independent sources, 9 reports
- 26 Sept 2026, 00:05 UTC: Unchained — 7 independent sources, 11 reports
- 26 Sept 2026, 15:30 UTC: NewsBTC — 8 independent sources, 14 reports
- 27 Sept 2026, 12:00 UTC: CoinDesk — 9 independent sources, 16 reports
- 27 Sept 2026, 13:01 UTC: Decrypt — 10 independent sources, 17 reports
- 28 Sept 2026, 08:52 UTC: U.Today — 11 independent sources, 18 reports
- 28 Sept 2026, 18:39 UTC: Cointelegraph — 12 independent sources, 19 reports
- 29 Sept 2026, 10:30 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 13 independent sources, 21 reports
- 1 Oct 2026, 21:09 UTC: Bitcoin Magazine — 14 independent sources, 23 reports
- 3 Oct 2026, 01:30 UTC: CryptoSlate — 15 independent sources, 27 reports
- 3 Oct 2026, 06:50 UTC: TheNewsCrypto — 16 independent sources, 30 reports
Affected entities
Also mentioned: Bitwise, Coinbase, Donald Trump, Michael Saylor, Paul Atkins, U.S. Congress, XRP