Federal Judge Rejects Joint Gemini-CFTC Bid to Vacate $5 Million Settlement
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein denied a joint motion by Gemini and the CFTC to overturn their January 2025 consent order, leaving the $5 million penalty and permanent injunction in place.
Why it matters
The decision establishes that a regulator's change in enforcement priorities cannot automatically erase a court-approved settlement, creating a precedent that limits the retroactive effect of policy shifts. For Gemini, the permanent injunction and public-denial restriction remain binding as the exchange expands into CFTC-regulated derivatives and prediction markets through its Apex Fintech partnership.
Where the sources disagree
Whether CFTC said it would not enforce the public denial restriction
CFTC said in June 2026 it would not enforce public denial restriction
Cointelegraph, CoinGape, Unchained, Crypto.News, Bitcoin.com News
No mention of CFTC waiving enforcement of public denial restriction
The Defiant, Crypto.News, CoinGape, CoinDesk, Unchained, Crypto.News, Bitcoin Insider, Decrypt, Bitcoin.com News, NewsBTC
Only Cointelegraph reports the CFTC said in June 2026 it would no longer enforce the restriction on Gemini publicly denying the settlement's findings; other sources do not mention this.
Key facts
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein denied a joint motion by Gemini and the CFTC to vacate their January 2025 consent order on October 15, 2026.
Disputed figureReported by The Defiant
The consent order entered in January 2025 required Gemini to pay a $5 million civil penalty and accept a permanent injunction against making false or misleading statements to the CFTC.
5,000,000 USDReported by The Defiant
Gemini has already paid the $5 million penalty, which the CFTC previously stated would not be refunded even if the settlement were overturned.
5,000,000 USDReported by The Defiant
The CFTC and Gemini filed a joint motion in May 2026 seeking to vacate the consent order after an internal CFTC review concluded the case should not have been brought under current enforcement standards.
Disputed figureReported by Crypto.News
The CFTC's internal review alleged enforcement misconduct including reliance on a questionable whistleblower, improper regulatory pressure, and efforts to prevent disclosure of evidence.
Reported by Cointelegraph
The original CFTC lawsuit filed in June 2022 alleged Gemini gave false or misleading information during the agency's review of a proposed bitcoin futures contract that would have settled on an auction price from Gemini's own platform.
Reported by Unchained
Judge Hellerstein ruled that neither the CFTC's changed enforcement priorities nor allegations of enforcement misconduct met the legal standard under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60 to justify vacating the settlement.
Reported by Crypto.News
The consent order also prohibits Gemini from publicly denying the settlement's findings, though the CFTC said in June 2026 it would no longer enforce this restriction.
Disputed figureReported by Cointelegraph
What happened
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein of the Southern District of New York ruled on October 15, 2026, denying a joint motion filed in May 2026 by crypto exchange Gemini and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to vacate their January 2025 consent order. The settlement, which resolved allegations that Gemini made false or misleading statements during the CFTC's 2017 review of a proposed bitcoin futures product, required a $5 million civil penalty and a permanent injunction barring Gemini from misleading the regulator or publicly denying the findings. Gemini had already paid the penalty. The CFTC joined Gemini in seeking relief after an internal review concluded the case should not have been brought under current enforcement priorities, influenced by a shift in policy under the new administration. Judge Hellerstein found that neither the policy shift nor allegations of enforcement misconduct — including reliance on a questionable whistleblower and improper regulatory pressure — met the strict standard under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60 to reopen a final judgment. The judge also rejected Gemini's argument that it had been coerced into settling. The ruling means the consent order remains fully in effect despite both parties' agreement to undo it.
How the story developed
- Resolution
Judge Hellerstein denies joint motion
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein ruled that policy shifts and misconduct allegations did not meet the Rule 60 standard to vacate the judgment.
- First report
First report by The Defiant
Judge Rejects Gemini-CFTC Bid to Lift Settlement Restrictions
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by Crypto.News
Gemini, CFTC lose bid to cancel $5 million penalty
- Update
CFTC and Gemini file joint motion to vacate settlement
After an internal review, both parties asked the court to overturn the consent order citing changed enforcement priorities and alleged enforcement misconduct.
- Update
CFTC files lawsuit against Gemini
CFTC charged Gemini with making false or misleading statements during review of a proposed bitcoin futures product.
- Official statement
Parties reach settlement before trial
Gemini and CFTC settled in December 2024, less than three weeks before a scheduled trial.
- Official statement
Court enters consent order
The consent order was entered on January 6, 2025, requiring a $5 million penalty and permanent injunction.
- Official statement
Official statement from Bitcoin.com News
Judge Refuses to Erase Gemini’s $5M Settlement Despite CFTC Reversal
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 16 Oct 2026, 00:39 UTC: The Defiant — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 05:05 UTC: Crypto.News — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 05:44 UTC: Bitcoin Insider — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 06:27 UTC: CoinGape — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 07:43 UTC: Cointelegraph — 5 independent sources, 5 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 09:36 UTC: CoinDesk — 6 independent sources, 6 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 10:26 UTC: Unchained — 7 independent sources, 7 reports
- 16 Oct 2026, 16:36 UTC: Decrypt — 8 independent sources, 10 reports
- 17 Oct 2026, 02:30 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 9 independent sources, 11 reports
- 17 Oct 2026, 10:13 UTC: NewsBTC — 10 independent sources, 13 reports
Affected entities
Also mentioned: Donald Trump, European Union, Chainlink
Original sources
Related events
New York sues Polymarket over alleged unlicensed gambling; Polymarket countersues
New York sued Polymarket US on September 24, 2026, alleging an unlicensed gambling operation; Polymarket countered the same day, moving the case to federal court.
Google rolls out Universal Cart in US Search and Gemini; court keeps Gemini CFTC settlement
Google began a US rollout of Universal Cart across Search and the Gemini app; in a separate case, a New York judge kept the Gemini exchange's five-million-dollar CFTC settlement standing.
Winklevoss Asset Services files S-1 for spot Zcash ETF to list on Nasdaq as WINK
Winklevoss Asset Services filed an SEC Form S-1 on October 6 for a spot Zcash ETF trading under WINK on Nasdaq with a 0.25% fee and Gemini as custodian.
Fairshake affiliate discloses $46.7 million in Ohio Senate race against Sherrod Brown
Defend American Jobs, a Fairshake affiliate, disclosed $46.67 million in Ohio spending against Sherrod Brown and for Jon Husted, above Fairshake's $30 million September pledge.
Gemini stock falls 80% from IPO price, prompting takeover speculation
Gemini's market value has dropped to about $753 million from roughly $4 billion at its peak, reviving questions about whether the Winklevoss-founded crypto platform could become an acquisition target.
Blockchain.com and Binance US seek US licenses for prediction market products
Blockchain.com and Binance US have applied for regulatory approval to offer event contracts in the United States, joining Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini and Bullish in the growing prediction market sector.