Commodity Futures Trading Commissionregulator
DisputedRegulationOfficial source

Senate fails to advance CLARITY Act 49-50; SEC and CFTC take over crypto rulemaking

The Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act in a 49-50 cloture vote on September 15, shifting crypto rulemaking to the SEC and CFTC, which moved within 48 hours to issue exemptions and begin formal rulemaking.

Why it matters

The failed vote moved crypto rulemaking from Congress to federal agencies, producing immediate regulatory actions but leaving the framework vulnerable to court challenges and reversal by a future administration. The midterm elections have become the next focal point for industry political spending.

Where the sources disagree

Whether the CLARITY Act could still pass in a lame-duck session

Can pass in lame-duck session

Bitcoin.com News

All but dead for the year

Decrypt

Rep. French Hill believes the bill can pass in a lame-duck session after the midterms, while Sen. Cynthia Lummis called the effort all but dead for the year.

Key facts

The Senate cloture vote on the CLARITY Act failed 49-50 on September 15, 2026.

Reported by CoinDesk

Democrats voted against the bill and three Republicans joined them after negotiations foundered on ethics provisions tied to President Trump's crypto ventures.

Reported by Decrypt

Senator Cynthia Lummis called the legislative effort all but dead for the year.

Reported by Decrypt

The CFTC filed 'Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets' with the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs on September 17 under RIN 3038-AF80.

Reported by Unchained

The CFTC issued a no-action position stating it would not recommend enforcement against passive software providers that connect users to registered derivatives firms without holding customer assets or routing orders.

Reported by Unchained

Fairshake PAC plans to spend $30 million opposing Senator Sherrod Brown in Ohio's Senate race.

30 million USDReported by Cointelegraph

What happened

On September 15 the Senate voted 49-50 on a cloture motion for the Digital Asset Market Clarity (CLARITY) Act, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed to proceed. Democrats voted against the bill and three Republicans joined them after negotiations foundered on ethics provisions tied to President Trump's crypto ventures, according to Decrypt. The defeat left U.S. crypto policy in the hands of the SEC and CFTC. Within two days the SEC issued a five-year innovation exemption for tokenized-stock trading, the CFTC filed a crypto market structure rulemaking with the White House budget office and issued a no-action position for software developers, and the Federal Reserve proposed stablecoin reserve rules under the GENIUS Act, Decrypt and Unchained reported. Industry figures including Chris Perkins of Franklin Crypto argued the regulatory path now provides sufficient clarity for institutions, while Rep. French Hill said agency rules fall short and vowed to push for passage in a lame-duck session after the midterms. Stand With Crypto, the Coinbase-backed advocacy group, responded by endorsing a bipartisan slate of more than 30 House candidates and several Senate contenders, and Fairshake PAC committed $30 million to oppose Senator Sherrod Brown in Ohio.

How the story developed

  1. Update

    Senate cloture vote on CLARITY Act fails

    49-50 vote falls 11 short of 60 needed

    U.Today

  2. First report

    First report by U.Today

    Ripple CEO: Don't Kill Crypto Bill

    U.Today

  3. Official statement

    SEC issues tokenized-stock innovation exemption

    Five-year exemption for onchain trading of tokenized U.S. stocks without exchange registration

    Unchained

  4. Official statement

    CFTC files crypto market structure rulemaking with White House

    Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets filed with OIRA under RIN 3038-AF80

    Unchained

  5. Official statement

    CFTC issues no-action relief for software developers

    Will not recommend enforcement against passive software providers connecting users to registered derivatives firms

    Unchained

  6. Independent corroboration

    Independently corroborated by CoinDesk

    Kevin O’Leary says Congress will revisit Clarity early next year as crypto tax bill advances

    CoinDesk

  7. Update

    Stand With Crypto announces bipartisan midterm endorsements

    Endorses 30+ House members and Senate candidates Jon Husted, Ashley Hinson, Chris Pappas

    Cointelegraph

  8. Official statement

    Official statement from Bitcoin.com News

    SEC Chair Paul Atkins Vows Onchain Rules Despite Failed CLAIRTY Act

    Bitcoin.com News

  9. Official statement

    Hester Peirce departs SEC

    Leaves agency with only two commissioners (Atkins and Uyeda) remaining

    Cointelegraph

How coverage built up

Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.

15 Sept, 07:4613 independent sources15 Oct, 17:00
  • 15 Sept 2026, 07:46 UTC: U.Today — 1 independent source, 1 reports
  • 15 Sept 2026, 17:56 UTC: U.Today — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
  • 17 Sept 2026, 18:40 UTC: CoinDesk — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
  • 21 Sept 2026, 10:11 UTC: Unchained — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
  • 21 Sept 2026, 20:01 UTC: Crypto News (CryptoNews.net) — 5 independent sources, 6 reports
  • 22 Sept 2026, 06:10 UTC: CryptoSlate — 6 independent sources, 7 reports
  • 22 Sept 2026, 15:10 UTC: Crypto.News — 7 independent sources, 11 reports
  • 22 Sept 2026, 15:55 UTC: Cointelegraph — 8 independent sources, 12 reports
  • 22 Sept 2026, 16:53 UTC: Blockchain.News — 9 independent sources, 13 reports
  • 26 Sept 2026, 16:06 UTC: Decrypt — 10 independent sources, 19 reports
  • 29 Sept 2026, 06:26 UTC: CoinGape — 11 independent sources, 23 reports
  • 30 Sept 2026, 09:01 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 12 independent sources, 26 reports
  • 1 Oct 2026, 19:04 UTC: CryptoPotato — 13 independent sources, 36 reports

Affected entities

Also mentioned: Bitwise, Coinbase, Cynthia Lummis, Donald Trump, Ethereum, Paul Atkins, Ripple

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Bitcoin.com News
Company, official
SEC Chair Paul Atkins Vows Onchain Rules Despite Failed CLAIRTY ActIndependent
Bitcoin.com News
Company, official
US Midterms: Stand With Crypto Backs Bipartisan Slate After Senate Bill FailsIndependent
Bitcoin.com News
Company, official
Rep. Hill Eyes Lame-Duck Session to Secure CLARITY Act ApprovalIndependent
U.Today
Crypto media
Ripple CEO: Don't Kill Crypto BillOriginal
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Kevin O’Leary says Congress will revisit Clarity early next year as crypto tax bill advancesIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Why banks and offshore hubs like Dubai are winners of the Senate killing the Clarity ActIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Crypto market structure can't wait for shot at post-election Clarity Act surge: White HouseIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Crypto for Advisors: The CLARITY Act failed, but the rules came anywayIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
The Clarity Act stalled. Bankers aren’t hitting the brakes yet on crypto dealmakingIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Clarity's failure could speed crypto innovation while shielding incumbentsIndependent
CoinDesk
Crypto media
Crypto for Advisors: Wall Street is done waiting on Congress for crypto rulesIndependent
Unchained
Crypto media
CFTC Sent Crypto Market Structure Rulemaking to the White House Two Days After Clarity Act FailedIndependent
Unchained
Crypto media
Crypto Got Its Rulebook Without Congress, Chris Perkins SaysIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
CLARITY vote failure could stoke more crypto PAC spending in key racesIndependent
Decrypt
Crypto media
How Crypto Stopped Waiting for Congress and Learned to Love the RegulatorsIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
Crypto regulation at SEC, CFTC to come down to 3 commissioners following key resignationIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
Crypto advocacy group announces picks for US Congress as midterms loomIndependent
Decrypt
Crypto media
Coinbase-Backed Crypto Group Reveals Midterm Endorsements After Clarity Act CollapseIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
CFTC joins SEC in proposing crypto framework after failed CLARITY voteIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
US crypto rules need to survive the next electionIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
House Finance panel chair says regulator actions on crypto ‘fall short’ of CLARITY billIndependent
Decrypt
Crypto media
SEC and CFTC Crypto Rules 'Fall Short' of Clarity, Says Rep. French HillIndependent
Cointelegraph
Crypto media
How the SEC’s lack of leadership could facilitate crypto rulemakingIndependent
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
Stand With Crypto’s 4 million registered advocates couldn’t get the CLARITY Act through the SenateIndependent
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
CLARITY Act needs 11 more Senate votes, but 4 of the 49 it already has want the bill changedIndependent
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
Bitcoin’s $113,000 case strengthens as US regulators push 9 crypto actionsIndependent
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
Trump’s crypto bill loses its White House negotiator as Patrick Witt exitsIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
Crypto firms still face full AML rules after CLARITY Act voteIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
CLARITY Act: Lummis blames Democrats after failed voteIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
CLARITY Act stalls as US crypto regulators write rules without CongressIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
CLARITY Act moves from the Senate floor to the campaign trailIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
CLARITY Act could allow 11 crypto activities for US banksIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
Why crypto rallied after the CLARITY Act failed, according to BitwiseIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
French Hill says SEC and CFTC crypto rules fall short of legislationIndependent
Crypto.News
Crypto media
The CLARITY Act stalled. Crypto’s election money faces a Senate testIndependent
CryptoPotato
Crypto media
Crypto May Be Better Off Without CLARITY Act, Says Bitwise CIO: ‘Too Big to Crush’Independent
CoinGape
Crypto media
White House, Senator Lummis Blame Democrats for Derailing CLARITY Act in SenateIndependent
CoinGape
Crypto media
It’s Over for Waiting on Congress: SEC and CFTC Make 9 Moves to Write Crypto Rules Without the CLARITY ActIndependent
CoinGape
Crypto media
From GENIUS to CLARITY: Congress Weighs On-Chain Banking for US DepositoriesIndependent
CoinGape
Crypto media
U.S. CFTC Proposes First Crypto Rules Under CTX and CAM After CLARITY Act FailsIndependent
U.Today
Crypto media
Ripple CEO Says Crypto Will Win With or Without Clarity ActSyndicated
Blockchain.News
Crypto media
CLARITY Act Vote Fails in Senate, Crypto Regulation DelayedSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Crypto ICOs Left in Limbo After CLARITY Act Fails in SenateSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
BitGo Research Analyzes CLARITY Act Vote and SEC/CFTCSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Why Crypto Rallied Instead Of Crashing After CLARITY Act FailedSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Democrats Block CLARITY Act Aimed at Protecting SeniorsSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
How Crypto Stopped Waiting for Congress and Learned to Love the RegulatorsSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Ripple News: Why Ripple’s CLO Says CLARITY Act’s Fate Doesn’t Matter For XRPSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
No CLARITY Act? Here’s how U.S. regulators are moving crypto forwardSyndicated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
Democrats Pushed Back on CLARITY Act, Drawing Blame from White House, LummisSyndicated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
Bitwise CIO’s Crypto Price Gain Claims Differ Across ReportsSyndicated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
Who Regulates Crypto in the United States? The SEC, the CFTC, Stablecoin Rules and What Congress Left UnfinishedSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
New SEC Crypto Custody Rules Underway as Clarity Act FailsSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
SEC Moves to Block Clarity Act Over Ethics LanguageSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Cryptocurrency market analysis shows 11% jump to $2.99 trillion in SeptemberSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
French Hill says SEC and CFTC crypto rules fall short of legislationSyndicated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
Outlets Disagree on When CLARITY Act Vote FailedSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
CFTC Chairman claims ‘we will go to war with the statute we’ve got’ as CLARITY Act failsSyndicated
Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Aggregator
Rep. Chris Pappas Advocates for CLARITY ActSyndicated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
Bitwise Says Four Crypto Sectors Gained After CLARITY Act StalledAggregated
Bitcoin Insider
Aggregator
US Crypto Policy Advances Even as CLARITY Act Stalls in CongressAggregated