Senate fails to advance CLARITY Act 49-50; SEC and CFTC take over crypto rulemaking
The Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act in a 49-50 cloture vote on September 15, shifting crypto rulemaking to the SEC and CFTC, which moved within 48 hours to issue exemptions and begin formal rulemaking.
Why it matters
The failed vote moved crypto rulemaking from Congress to federal agencies, producing immediate regulatory actions but leaving the framework vulnerable to court challenges and reversal by a future administration. The midterm elections have become the next focal point for industry political spending.
Where the sources disagree
Whether the CLARITY Act could still pass in a lame-duck session
Can pass in lame-duck session
Bitcoin.com News
All but dead for the year
Decrypt
Rep. French Hill believes the bill can pass in a lame-duck session after the midterms, while Sen. Cynthia Lummis called the effort all but dead for the year.
Key facts
The Senate cloture vote on the CLARITY Act failed 49-50 on September 15, 2026.
Reported by CoinDesk
Democrats voted against the bill and three Republicans joined them after negotiations foundered on ethics provisions tied to President Trump's crypto ventures.
Reported by Decrypt
Senator Cynthia Lummis called the legislative effort all but dead for the year.
Reported by Decrypt
The CFTC filed 'Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets' with the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs on September 17 under RIN 3038-AF80.
Reported by Unchained
The CFTC issued a no-action position stating it would not recommend enforcement against passive software providers that connect users to registered derivatives firms without holding customer assets or routing orders.
Reported by Unchained
Fairshake PAC plans to spend $30 million opposing Senator Sherrod Brown in Ohio's Senate race.
30 million USDReported by Cointelegraph
What happened
On September 15 the Senate voted 49-50 on a cloture motion for the Digital Asset Market Clarity (CLARITY) Act, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed to proceed. Democrats voted against the bill and three Republicans joined them after negotiations foundered on ethics provisions tied to President Trump's crypto ventures, according to Decrypt. The defeat left U.S. crypto policy in the hands of the SEC and CFTC. Within two days the SEC issued a five-year innovation exemption for tokenized-stock trading, the CFTC filed a crypto market structure rulemaking with the White House budget office and issued a no-action position for software developers, and the Federal Reserve proposed stablecoin reserve rules under the GENIUS Act, Decrypt and Unchained reported. Industry figures including Chris Perkins of Franklin Crypto argued the regulatory path now provides sufficient clarity for institutions, while Rep. French Hill said agency rules fall short and vowed to push for passage in a lame-duck session after the midterms. Stand With Crypto, the Coinbase-backed advocacy group, responded by endorsing a bipartisan slate of more than 30 House candidates and several Senate contenders, and Fairshake PAC committed $30 million to oppose Senator Sherrod Brown in Ohio.
How the story developed
- Update
Senate cloture vote on CLARITY Act fails
49-50 vote falls 11 short of 60 needed
- First report
First report by U.Today
Ripple CEO: Don't Kill Crypto Bill
- Official statement
SEC issues tokenized-stock innovation exemption
Five-year exemption for onchain trading of tokenized U.S. stocks without exchange registration
- Official statement
CFTC files crypto market structure rulemaking with White House
Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets filed with OIRA under RIN 3038-AF80
- Official statement
CFTC issues no-action relief for software developers
Will not recommend enforcement against passive software providers connecting users to registered derivatives firms
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by CoinDesk
Kevin O’Leary says Congress will revisit Clarity early next year as crypto tax bill advances
- Update
Stand With Crypto announces bipartisan midterm endorsements
Endorses 30+ House members and Senate candidates Jon Husted, Ashley Hinson, Chris Pappas
- Official statement
Official statement from Bitcoin.com News
SEC Chair Paul Atkins Vows Onchain Rules Despite Failed CLAIRTY Act
- Official statement
Hester Peirce departs SEC
Leaves agency with only two commissioners (Atkins and Uyeda) remaining
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 15 Sept 2026, 07:46 UTC: U.Today — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 15 Sept 2026, 17:56 UTC: U.Today — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
- 17 Sept 2026, 18:40 UTC: CoinDesk — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
- 21 Sept 2026, 10:11 UTC: Unchained — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
- 21 Sept 2026, 20:01 UTC: Crypto News (CryptoNews.net) — 5 independent sources, 6 reports
- 22 Sept 2026, 06:10 UTC: CryptoSlate — 6 independent sources, 7 reports
- 22 Sept 2026, 15:10 UTC: Crypto.News — 7 independent sources, 11 reports
- 22 Sept 2026, 15:55 UTC: Cointelegraph — 8 independent sources, 12 reports
- 22 Sept 2026, 16:53 UTC: Blockchain.News — 9 independent sources, 13 reports
- 26 Sept 2026, 16:06 UTC: Decrypt — 10 independent sources, 19 reports
- 29 Sept 2026, 06:26 UTC: CoinGape — 11 independent sources, 23 reports
- 30 Sept 2026, 09:01 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 12 independent sources, 26 reports
- 1 Oct 2026, 19:04 UTC: CryptoPotato — 13 independent sources, 36 reports
Affected entities
Also mentioned: Bitwise, Coinbase, Cynthia Lummis, Donald Trump, Ethereum, Paul Atkins, Ripple