CFTC sends two swap-definition rules to OIRA as Sixth Circuit lets state gambling laws apply
The CFTC sent OIRA two rules redrawing the swap definition for event contracts, days after the Sixth Circuit held Kalshi's sports contracts are not swaps and state gambling laws can apply.
Why it matters
The inclusion rule would put a rulemaking record behind the CFTC's claim that event contracts are federally regulated swaps, a claim appeals courts rejected for sports contracts days earlier. Bitcoin.com notes the CFTC has sued nine states over attempts to block sports event contracts, so the rulemaking and the state litigation pursue the same jurisdictional question; nothing binds anyone until the rules are published and effective.
Where the sources disagree
Legal status of the two CFTC submissions to OIRA
one proposed rule (RIN 3038-AF82) and one interim final rule (RIN 3038-AF81)
Decrypt, Crypto.News
two proposed rules
Bitcoin Insider
Decrypt and Crypto.News describe one proposed rule and one interim final rule, while Bitcoin Insider describes the pair as two proposed rules.
Scope of the Sixth Circuit decision
Kalshi's preliminary injunction against Tennessee stripped away
Bankless
Ohio and Tennessee may apply state gambling laws
Crypto.News
Bankless frames the ruling as stripping Kalshi's preliminary injunction against Tennessee, while Crypto.Newz reports the court cleared both Ohio and Tennessee to apply their gambling laws.
Where the appellate conflict stands procedurally
the fight heads toward the Supreme Court
Bankless
conflicting appeals-court rulings now before the Supreme Court
Decrypt
Bankless says the fight is heading toward the Supreme Court, while Decrypt says the conflicting appellate rulings are already before it.
Key facts
The CFTC sent OIRA two documents on September 28: proposed rule RIN 3038-AF82, a further definition of swap to include event contracts, and RIN 3038-AF81, an interim final rule to exclude casino-style gambling products.
Disputed figureReported by Decrypt
The Sixth Circuit ruled on September 25 that the sports contracts before it do not qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act and that federal commodities law does not prevent states from applying their gambling laws.
Reported by Crypto.News
Bankless puts the appellate scoreboard at 2-1 against Kalshi, with the Ninth Circuit also rejecting federal CFTC pre-emption of state gambling laws and the Third Circuit the only appellate court in Kalshi's favour.
Reported by Bankless
Neither September 28 submission had been published in the Federal Register or in force as of October 1, and Decrypt reports the CFTC classified both as not economically significant.
Reported by Crypto.News
CFTC data shows designated markets certified about 1,600 new event contracts in 2025, against roughly five a year in 2006-2020.
1,600 event contractsReported by Crypto.News
An August CFTC staff advisory gave exchanges until September 14 to bring incentive programmes into line and flagged 'risk-free' trades, unlimited rebates and chance-based bonuses.
Reported by Bitcoin.com News
What happened
On September 28 the Commodity Futures Trading Commission sent two documents to the White House's Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs: proposed rule RIN 3038-AF82, titled as a further definition of swap to include event contracts, and RIN 3038-AF81, an interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products. Decrypt reports the agency classified both as not economically significant and Crypto.News says neither had been published in the Federal Register or in force as of October 1, so no rule text is public. The swap label decides whether the CFTC has authority over contracts traded on platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket, and state regulators have disputed that claim specifically for sports event contracts. On September 25 the Sixth Circuit held that the sports contracts before it are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act and that federal commodities law does not stop states from applying their gambling laws, which Crypto.News says means Ohio and Tennessee can proceed; Bankless describes the same decision as stripping away Kalshi's preliminary injunction against Tennessee and puts the appellate scoreboard at 2-1 against Kalshi, with the Ninth Circuit also rejecting federal pre-emption and the Third Circuit the only appellate court in Kalshi's favour. Bankless says the fight is heading toward the Supreme Court while Decrypt says the conflicting appellate rulings are already before it, so the route those rulings take is not settled by the reporting. Separately, Bitcoin.com reports the CFTC is sweeping over prediction market incentive programmes, citing Front Office Sports on September 29: an August staff advisory gave exchanges until September 14 to bring flagged 'risk-free' trades, unlimited rebates and chance-based bonuses into line, action of some kind was expected by the end of that week, Chairman Michael Selig had not settled on an approach, and the CFTC declined to comment.
How the story developed
- Update
Sixth Circuit holds sports contracts are not swaps
The court also held that federal commodities law does not bar Ohio or Tennessee from applying their gambling laws.
- Official statement
CFTC submits two event-contract rules to OIRA
RIN 3038-AF82 would include event contracts in the swap definition; RIN 3038-AF81 would exclude casino-style gambling products.
- First report
First report by Bankless
States Pull Ahead in Prediction Market Fight
- Update
Front Office Sports reports CFTC incentive review
Cited by Bitcoin.com as the source for a possible CFTC action on prediction market bonuses expected by the end of the week.
- Official statement
Official statement from Bitcoin.com News
CFTC Readies Action on Prediction Market Promos, Expected This Week
- Update
Decrypt reports the OIRA submissions
Describes both as not economically significant, with full text not yet public.
- Update
Cointelegraph corroborates the docket contents
Cites the OIRA docket showing the proposed inclusion rule and the casino-style interim final rule under review.
- Update
Crypto.News confirms neither rule is operative
Neither September 28 submission had appeared as a published, operative rule as of October 1.
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 28 Sept 2026, 18:06 UTC: Bankless — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 30 Sept 2026, 12:35 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
- 30 Sept 2026, 18:39 UTC: Decrypt — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
- 1 Oct 2026, 01:07 UTC: Cointelegraph — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
- 1 Oct 2026, 10:15 UTC: Crypto.News — 5 independent sources, 5 reports
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin.com News Company, official | CFTC Readies Action on Prediction Market Promos, Expected This Week | Independent | |
| Bankless Crypto media | States Pull Ahead in Prediction Market Fight | Original | |
| Decrypt Crypto media | CFTC Sends White House New Rules to Cement Its Grip on Prediction Markets | Independent | |
| Cointelegraph Crypto media | CFTC seeks to define event contracts as swaps amid prediction market fight | Independent | |
| Crypto.News Crypto media | The CFTC has sent prediction market rules to the White House. States are still in court | Independent | |
| Bitcoin Insider Aggregator | White House to Review Pair of CFTC Prediction Market Rules | Aggregated |