Sony Argues in Court That Players Do Not Own the Digital Games They Bought
Decrypt reports Sony is arguing in court that players do not own the digital games they buy, in a long-running dispute over digital ownership.
Why it matters
If a court accepts Sony's position that digital purchases convey no ownership rights, the precedent would reach beyond games to other digital media sold through storefronts. It also gives encrypted NFT projects a defined pitch: the gap between owning a record of purchase and controlling the file. With one source and no Sony statement in evidence, the immediate significance for markets is limited.
Key facts
Sony is arguing in court that digital games cannot be owned by the players who bought them.
Reported by Decrypt
Traditional property law protections against seizure do not apply to digital assets, leaving platform operators free to revoke or edit content a user has paid for.
Reported by Decrypt
Kostas Chalkias, co-founder and chief cryptographer at Mysten Labs, said the dispute over digital ownership is still in its early innings.
Reported by Decrypt
Mysten Labs is pitching encrypted NFTs as a fix for the weaknesses of conventional NFTs, namely public metadata and reliance on centrally hosted files.
Reported by Decrypt
Amazon Kindle owners found their ebook copies of George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four were remotely deleted in 2009 as a result of a rights issue.
Reported by Decrypt
Since then, publishers have remotely edited works by Roald Dahl, Agatha Christie and R.L. Stine on Amazon, and film and TV titles have been purged from digital libraries.
Reported by Decrypt
Decrypt is the only outlet in this evidence set covering the Sony court argument.
Reported by Decrypt
What happened
Decrypt reported that Sony is arguing in court that digital games cannot be owned by the players who bought them, the latest dispute over who holds rights to purchased digital content. Under the argument described, traditional property law protections against seizure do not cover digital assets, which leaves platform operators free to revoke or edit content a user has paid for. Kostas Chalkias, co-founder and chief cryptographer at Mysten Labs, told Decrypt the fight is 'still in its early innings', adding that with media, people are used to renting and streaming and increasingly finding that the things they think they are buying do not belong to them. Decrypt noted the issue extends past video games, pointing to Amazon Kindle owners who found their copies of George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four remotely deleted over a rights issue in 2009, and later remote edits to works by Roald Dahl, Agatha Christie and R.L. Stine, alongside films and TV titles purged from digital libraries. Decrypt also reported that NFTs give holders a verifiable self-held record of ownership, but that public metadata and reliance on centrally hosted files have limited that promise, which is the problem encrypted NFTs are being pitched to solve. No Sony court filing, ruling date or response from Sony appears in the evidence, and the claim rests on a single outlet.
How the story developed
- First report
First report by Decrypt
Sony Says You Don't Own the Games You Bought. Crypto Says It Can Fix That
- Update
Sony argues in court that players do not own the digital games they buy
Decrypt reported Sony's court position that digital games cannot be owned by the players who bought them, arguing traditional property law protections against seizure do not cover digital assets.
- Update
Mysten Labs chief cryptographer comments on the digital ownership dispute
Kostas Chalkias told Decrypt the dispute is still in its early innings, saying buyers of media increasingly find the things they think they are buying do not belong to them.
- Update
Encrypted NFTs pitched as a fix for NFT ownership limits
Decrypt reported that public metadata and reliance on centrally hosted files have limited what NFTs promise, and that encrypted NFTs are being marketed to address that.
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decrypt Crypto media | Sony Says You Don't Own the Games You Bought. Crypto Says It Can Fix That | Original |