BitcoinBTC, coin
DevelopingProtocol update

Bitcoin draft BIP461 sets deterministic ECDSA signing to expose hidden key leaks

Bitcoin proposal BIP461, merged into the BIPs repository on Sept. 16 and still Draft, would require reproducible ECDSA signatures so signers can check for hidden key leakage.

Why it matters

A signing specification that operators can compare against their own output gives hardware and wallet signer makers a way to test whether firmware is leaking key material, and doing so needs no protocol fork or miner vote because the signatures are already consensus-valid. With one source and the proposal still in Draft, the effect on Bitcoin users at present is limited.

Key facts

BIP461 was merged into the BIPs repository on Sept. 16 and is still marked Draft.

Reported by CryptoSlate

BIP461 was authored by Liam Gilligan.

Reported by CryptoSlate

The proposal requires a deterministic ECDSA signing procedure so independent compliant signers produce identical signatures for the same secret key and message hash.

Reported by CryptoSlate

The signatures defined by BIP461 work under existing Bitcoin consensus rules, so implementing the procedure requires no consensus change.

Reported by CryptoSlate

Comparing signatures for deviations requires another signer with access to the secret key.

Reported by CryptoSlate

What happened

CryptoSlate reported that Bitcoin improvement proposal BIP461 was merged into the BIPs repository on Sept. 16 and remains marked Draft. Written by Liam Gilligan, it defines a deterministic signing procedure for ECDSA, Bitcoin's existing signature scheme, so that any compliant signer using the same secret key and message hash produces an identical signature, giving signers a benchmark for spotting departures that could conceal key leakage. CryptoSlate said the signatures already validate under existing Bitcoin consensus rules, so implementing the procedure requires no consensus change. The proposal targets a property of ECDSA that lets a signer choose values, including the nonce, while still producing a valid signature, which CryptoSlate said malicious firmware can exploit to hide key material in signatures that pass verification. The outlet cautioned that differing signatures show at least one signer departed from the procedure without establishing malice, that matching samples can miss conditional leaks, and that the comparison requires another signer with access to the secret key. CryptoSlate gave no implementation date or adoption commitment, and no other outlet covered the story.

How the story developed

  1. Official statement

    BIP461 merged into the BIPs repository

    The proposal by Liam Gilligan entered the repository on Sept. 16 and remains in Draft.

    CryptoSlate

  2. First report

    First report by CryptoSlate

    New Bitcoin upgrade catches hidden key leaks hiding the exact fix

    CryptoSlate

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
New Bitcoin upgrade catches hidden key leaks hiding the exact fixOriginal