USD CoinUSDC, token
DisputedSecurity

Protos finds HTX proof of reserves does not match on-chain balances

Protos reported that HTX's September proof of reserves listed USDS and USDD balances that did not match the amounts actually held at the stated block height.

Why it matters

The claim touches a reserve attestation that a single exchange publishes about its own solvency, and no external auditor or second outlet has confirmed it. Until HTX responds, the accuracy of its published reserve figures is open question rather than established fact.

Where the sources disagree

USDS balance at the address listed in HTX's September proof of reserves

360949.90 USDS claimed at block height 25876316

Protos

0 USDS reported at block height 25876316

Protos

HTX's proof of reserves claims 360949.90 USDS sat in the address at block height 25876316, while Protos reports the address held 0 USDS at that height.

Key facts

Protos said the only transaction in which that address received USDS was at block height 25889452, on September 2.

Reported by Protos

Protos reported that the address held 44,886,000 USDD at block height 25876316.

44,886,000 USDDDisputed figureReported by Protos

The proof of reserves is dated September 1 and the first USDS receipt into the address came on September 2, according to Protos.

Reported by Protos

Protos previously reported that HTX's May proof of reserves listed a STEAK-USDC amount that the named address did not hold at the claimed block height, though an equivalent amount of sUSDS was there.

Disputed figureReported by Protos

Protos said HTX did not respond to its request for comment before publication.

Reported by Protos

What happened

Protos reported that HTX, the exchange owned by Justin Sun, claimed in its September proof of reserves that it held 360949.90 USDS in address 0xdaa4393013f359fd63a133a3b893d311aba4e471 at block height 25876316, but that address held 0 USDS at that block height according to Protos. Protos said the only transaction in which that address received USDS came at block height 25889452, on September 2, after the proof of reserves dated September 1. Protos also reported that the same proof of reserves claimed 44,975,772.00 of the Sun-founded USDD in 0x18709e89bd403f470088abdacebe86cc60dda12e at block height 25876316, while the address held 44,886,000 USDD at that block height. Protos said this was not the first such problem, pointing to its earlier reporting that a May proof of reserves listed STEAK-USDC that the named address did not hold at the claimed block height, though an equivalent amount of sUSDS was there, which Protos read as a mix-up between the two assets. Protos said it contacted HTX for comment and that HTX had not responded before publication. No other outlet covered the claim, and HTX's side of the discrepancy is not on the record.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by Protos

    HTX’s proof of reserves doesn’t match its blockchain balances

    Protos

  2. Update

    Protos publishes the HTX proof of reserves discrepancy

    Protos reports that HTX's September proof of reserves lists USDS and USDD balances that do not match on-chain holdings at the stated block height, and notes HTX had not responded to a request for comment.

    Protos

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Protos
Crypto media
HTX’s proof of reserves doesn’t match its blockchain balancesOriginal