U.S. Securities and Exchange Commissionregulator
DevelopingRegulation

SEC's departing Peirce Urges Cryptographic Proofs to Replace KYC Data Collection

Decrypt reports that outgoing SEC commissioner Hester Peirce told SIFMA that zero-knowledge proofs could verify age or sanctions status without collecting the personal data KYC requires.

Why it matters

Peirce is leaving the commission, so the speech carries no rulemaking weight on its own. The mechanism she described, proving a fact without handing over the record behind it, is the argument regulators and industry groups will have to address if identity-data collection stays under scrutiny after the Revolut and Trezor-related leaks.

Key facts

Hester Peirce, a departing SEC commissioner, spoke at SIFMA's Digital Assets Conference in New York on Wednesday.

Reported by Decrypt

Peirce said the KYC and anti-money laundering regime rests on the flawed premise that collecting enough information on enough people helps authorities find criminals among the law-abiding.

Reported by Decrypt

Peirce said regulators build ever bigger data haystacks on the theory that a needle or two will turn up inside, and that the bigger haystack makes the needles harder to find.

Reported by Decrypt

Peirce warned against 'data maximalists' who assume that collecting more information is always better.

Reported by Decrypt

Peirce said zero-knowledge proofs, a cryptographic method that verifies a fact without exposing the underlying data, and attribute-based credentials could confirm details such as age or sanctions status without revealing personal data.

Reported by Decrypt

Decrypt reported a recent Revolut leak that exposed passports and Bitcoin transaction histories.

Reported by Decrypt

Decrypt reported vendor breaches affecting Trezor, which Peirce said added to 'wrench attack' fears.

Reported by Decrypt

Peirce argued that regulators' demand for personal data has built large, hackable collections that endanger the people those rules are meant to protect.

Reported by Decrypt

What happened

Decrypt reported that Hester Peirce, a departing commissioner at the US SEC, used her appearance at SIFMA's Digital Assets Conference in New York on Wednesday to attack the know-your-customer and anti-money laundering regime. She said the system rests on a faulty premise, that gathering enough information about enough people will let authorities find criminals among the law-abiding. 'We build ever bigger data haystacks on the theory that we will find a needle or two inside,' she said, adding that a larger haystack makes the needles harder to find, and warning against 'data maximalists' who assume additional collection is always better. Peirce said zero-knowledge proofs, which verify a fact without exposing the underlying data, together with attribute-based credentials, could confirm matters such as age or sanctions status without collecting personal records. Decrypt set the remarks against a run of identity leaks, including Revolut exposing passports and Bitcoin transaction histories and vendor breaches affecting Trezor, which Peirce linked to 'wrench attack' fears about people coercing targets for their data. Only Decrypt covered the speech, and its account described no official response, no rule change and no other participant's reaction.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by Decrypt

    In Her Final Weeks, SEC's Peirce Calls for Ending the KYC 'Panopticon'

    Decrypt

  2. Update

    Decrypt publishes its account of Peirce's SIFMA speech

    The only report in the evidence set describes the remarks and their context.

    Decrypt

  3. Official statement

    Peirce argues for cryptographic verification at SIFMA in New York

    Speaking Wednesday, the departing commissioner called the KYC and AML premise flawed and promoted zero-knowledge proofs and attribute-based credentials.

    Decrypt

  4. Update

    Identity leaks at Revolut and Trezor's vendors cited as context

    Passport and Bitcoin history exposure at Revolut and vendor breaches affecting Trezor were cited as the backdrop for Peirce's warnings about 'wrench attack' risks.

    Decrypt

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Decrypt
Crypto media
In Her Final Weeks, SEC's Peirce Calls for Ending the KYC 'Panopticon'Original