Fed's September rate hike wipes out October cut odds and puts a second increase in play
After the Fed's Sept. 16 hike, its first in over three years, Polymarket, Kalshi and CME traders shifted to betting on another quarter-point rise at the Oct. 28 meeting.
Why it matters
The Fed's first hike in three years reversed the cut expectations traders held a month earlier, and three prediction platforms now lean toward a second straight increase at the Oct. 28 meeting. The odds reflect only what bettors on those platforms have wagered, not the Fed's stated plans.
Where the sources disagree
Odds of an October rate hike
56% (Polymarket)
Bitcoin.com News
57.6% (futures traders)
Bitcoin.com News
54% (Kalshi)
Bitcoin.com News
Bitcoin.com News cites three platforms that each put a different probability on a further quarter-point increase at the Oct. 28 meeting.
Key facts
The Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate on Sept. 16, 2026, its first increase in more than three years.
Reported by Bitcoin.com News
The Fed had gone 1,148 days between rate increases.
1,148 daysReported by Bitcoin.com News
On Aug. 19, 2026, CME futures priced a 53.6% chance the Fed would cut 25 basis points at its October meeting.
53.6 %Reported by Bitcoin.com News
By Sept. 19, 2026, the October cut probability had fallen to 0%.
0 %Reported by Bitcoin.com News
Futures traders gave a further quarter-point increase 57.6% probability, against 42.4% for leaving rates unchanged.
57.6 %Disputed figureReported by Bitcoin.com News
CME traders saw a 90.1% chance that rates finish December above today's range.
90.1 %Reported by Bitcoin.com News
Polymarket bettors gave another October Fed hike 56% odds, against 44% for a pause.
56 %Disputed figureReported by Bitcoin.com News
Kalshi bettors priced a quarter-point Fed hike on Oct. 28 at 54%, against 44% for rates staying put.
54 %Disputed figureReported by Bitcoin.com News
What happened
Bitcoin.com News reports that trader expectations flipped after the Federal Reserve's Sept. 16 rate hike, the first in more than three years and the end of a 1,148-day gap between increases. On Aug. 19, 2026, CME futures priced a 53.6% chance of a 25-basis-point cut at the October meeting; as of Sept. 19 that probability has fallen to 0%. Futures traders now give a further quarter-point increase 57.6% odds against 42.4% for unchanged rates, and CME traders see a 90.1% chance that rates finish December above the current range. Polymarket bettors put the October hike at 56% versus 44% for a pause, and Kalshi bettors price a quarter-point hike on Oct. 28 at 54% against 44% for rates staying put. Every figure comes from the single report by Bitcoin.com News, so none are independently confirmed.
How the story developed
- Update
Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate, its first increase in more than three years
The hike ended a 1,148-day stretch without an increase and reset expectations for the Oct. 28 meeting.
- First report
First report by Bitcoin.com News
Fed’s Next Rate Move Has Traders Staring at a Coin Toss
- Update
CME futures priced a 53.6% chance of an October rate cut
A month before the Fed meeting, futures traders still saw a cut as the likeliest outcome.
- Update
Bitcoin.com News published its account of the shift in rate expectations
First and only report covering the story; all odds are attributed to it.
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin.com News Company, official | Fed’s Next Rate Move Has Traders Staring at a Coin Toss | Original |