EthereumETH, coin
DisputedGovernance

About 95% of ATOM Cast Voted to Veto Cosmos Hub Refund Proposal for Neutron Attacker

Unchained reports about 95% of the 69.3 million ATOM cast on Cosmos Hub proposal 1056 backed no-with-veto, blocking a 1,221,120 ATOM refund to the Neutron attacker.

Why it matters

The vote decides whether about 1.2 million ATOM taken during the Neutron incident returns to the attacker address and whether the Hub community pool funds a 500,000 ATOM payout to yes voters; if the veto holds, the ATOM stays under the control of the 4-of-6 validator multisig. The underlying dispute is whether the Hub took the ATOM unjustly, which the proposal asserts and the Hub team denies.

Where the sources disagree

Whether the Cosmos Hub acted wrongly in taking the ATOM

Hub reps coordinated validators to unjustifiably steal the ATOM (proposal text)

Unchained

There was no vulnerability on the Cosmos Hub and the patch touched exactly one account (Hub team)

Unchained

The proposal text accuses Hub reps of coordinating validators to unjustifiably steal the ATOM, while the Hub team said in its Thursday update that there was no vulnerability on the Hub and the patch touched exactly one account.

Key facts

By 2:34 p.m. ET on Friday, no-with-veto votes accounted for about 95% of the roughly 69.3 million ATOM cast on Cosmos Hub proposal 1056.

95 %Reported by Unchained

About 174,300 ATOM were cast in favour of proposal 1056 as of the same Friday tally.

174,300 ATOMReported by Unchained

Proposal 1056, titled 'ATOM Refund & Justice Bounty' on-chain and submitted at 7:20 p.m. ET on Wednesday, asks for 1,221,120 ATOM to be returned to the attacker address.

1,221,120 ATOMDisputed figureReported by Unchained

The proposal offers a 500,000 ATOM 'Justice Bounty' to yes voters, split by staking weight, paid over six months and capped at 5,000 ATOM per voter.

500,000 ATOMReported by Unchained

A message attached to the proposal would pay 1,721,120 ATOM from the Hub community pool to the address that submitted it, which Unchained reported is different from the address the Hub swept.

1,721,120 ATOMReported by Unchained

A Neutron governance vote that closed on the night of Sept. 21 gave an attacker admin control of contracts run by Astroport and Drop, after which validators halted and restarted the chain.

Reported by Unchained

The Wednesday restart moved the attacker's remaining 1,227,121 ATOM into a 4-of-6 multisig held by Hub validators including Nansen, Keplr, Enigma, Silknodes and Kiln.

1,227,121 ATOMReported by Unchained

In its Thursday weekly update the Hub team wrote that 'there was no vulnerability on the Cosmos Hub' and that the patched software 'touched exactly one account'.

Disputed figureReported by Unchained

What happened

Unchained reported that Cosmos Hub proposal 1056, titled 'ATOM Refund & Justice Bounty' on-chain, was drawing a near-unanimous veto, with no-with-veto votes at about 95% of the roughly 69.3 million ATOM cast by 2:34 p.m. ET on Friday against about 174,300 ATOM in favour. The proposal, submitted at 7:20 p.m. ET on Wednesday, asks for 1,221,120 ATOM to be returned to the attacker address and states that 'Cosmos Hub reps coordinated validators to unjustifiably steal 1.2M ATOM', and it offers a 500,000 ATOM 'Justice Bounty' to yes voters, split by staking weight, paid over six months and capped at 5,000 ATOM per voter. Unchained also reported that a message attached to the proposal would pay 1,721,120 ATOM from the Hub community pool to the submitting address, which Unchained said differs from the address the Hub swept. The ATOM came from Neutron, where a governance vote closing on the night of Sept. 21 gave an attacker admin control of contracts run by Astroport and Drop, and a chain restart on Wednesday moved 1,227,121 remaining ATOM into a 4-of-6 multisig whose signers are Hub validators including Nansen, Keplr, Enigma, Silknodes and Kiln. In its Thursday weekly update, the Hub team wrote that 'there was no vulnerability on the Cosmos Hub' and that the patched software 'touched exactly one account', a position the proposal text contradicts. Unchained is the only outlet reporting this story, and the voting period was still open when it published.

How the story developed

  1. Update

    Neutron governance vote gives attacker admin control of Astroport and Drop contracts

    The vote closed on the night of Sept. 21; validators then halted and restarted the chain.

    Unchained

  2. Update

    Chain restart moves 1,227,121 ATOM into a 4-of-6 validator multisig

    Validators restarted Neutron and moved the attacker address's remaining ATOM into a multisig.

    Unchained

  3. Update

    Proposal 1056 goes on-chain with refund and bounty terms

    The proposal titled 'ATOM Refund & Justice Bounty' was submitted at 7:20 p.m. ET and carries a message to pay 1,721,120 ATOM to the submitting address.

    Unchained

  4. Official statement

    Hub team denies any Cosmos Hub vulnerability

    In a weekly update the Hub team wrote that 'there was no vulnerability on the Cosmos Hub' and that the patched software 'touched exactly one account'.

    Unchained

  5. First report

    First report by Unchained

    Cosmos Hub Voters Are Vetoing a Proposal to Refund the Neutron Attacker 1.2 Million ATOM

    Unchained

  6. Update

    Unchained reports near-unanimous no-with-veto support on proposal 1056

    The outlet put no-with-veto at about 95% of roughly 69.3 million ATOM cast as of 2:34 p.m. ET, with about 174,300 ATOM in favour, and noted voting was still open.

    Unchained

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Unchained
Crypto media
Cosmos Hub Voters Are Vetoing a Proposal to Refund the Neutron Attacker 1.2 Million ATOMOriginal