Baseprotocol
DevelopingGovernance

MAXYZ asks Balancer DAO for up to 6 million BAL to seed a successor protocol

MAXYZ, a group of former Balancer contributors, wants up to 6 million non-circulating BAL to seed a successor protocol, which CryptoSlate says could dilute existing holders' wind-down redemption.

Why it matters

The request, if approved, would enlarge the pool of tokens eligible for a treasury payout that existing BAL holders would otherwise share among themselves, so the same treasury would be divided among more tokens. CryptoSlate framed the unresolved question for holders as how much of the grant would become redeemable and whether a future stake in the fork offsets a smaller share of the old treasury; no decision has been reported.

Key facts

MAXYZ, a group of former Balancer contributors, is asking the Balancer DAO for up to 6 million currently non-circulating BAL to seed a successor protocol.

6,000,000 BALReported by CryptoSlate

A separate Balancer wind-down plan would let BAL holders burn their tokens for a pro rata share of the DAO's remaining assets.

Reported by CryptoSlate

MAXYZ listed about 3.5 million BAL in the treasury, 1.6 million in a Balancer Labs fundraise safe and 928,000 in a Labs team safe as its proposed seed.

3,500,000 BALReported by CryptoSlate

MAXYZ proposes a contingent allocation from the future fork to the Balancer treasury in exchange for the grant, which CryptoSlate described as an asset with no realized value today.

Reported by CryptoSlate

The fork proposal was posted Sept. 20 and expanded in a Sept. 23 FAQ.

Reported by CryptoSlate

Neither forum proposal by itself transfers tokens, changes pool operations or gives the fork rights to the code, and the grant, technology rights and redemption terms each need separate decisions.

Reported by CryptoSlate

What happened

MAXYZ, a group of former Balancer contributors, has asked the Balancer DAO for up to 6 million currently non-circulating BAL to seed a successor protocol, CryptoSlate reported. The proposal, posted Sept. 20 and expanded in a Sept. 23 FAQ, runs alongside a separate wind-down plan under which BAL holders would burn their tokens for a pro rata share of the DAO's remaining assets. CryptoSlate said that if the granted tokens reach other eligible holders before the proposed wind-down snapshot, the same treasury would be split among more BAL, leaving each existing holder with a smaller share. MAXYZ identified about 3.5 million BAL in the treasury, 1.6 million in a Balancer Labs fundraise safe and 928,000 in a Labs team safe as its proposed seed, and proposed in return a contingent allocation from the future fork to the Balancer treasury, which CryptoSlate described as an asset with no realized value today. CryptoSlate noted that neither forum proposal by itself moves tokens, changes pool operations or grants the fork rights to the code, and that the grant, technology rights and redemption terms each need separate decisions. Because only CryptoSlate covered the story, the request, the proposed compensation and the effect on redemption values are all unconfirmed claims from that single outlet.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by CryptoSlate

    Balancer fork’s 6 million BAL ask could cut holders’ redemption value

    CryptoSlate

  2. Update

    MAXYZ posts fork proposal asking for up to 6 million BAL

    The proposal asks for non-circulating BAL to seed a successor protocol and offers a contingent allocation from the future fork to the treasury.

    CryptoSlate

  3. Update

    MAXYZ expands the proposal in a Sept. 23 FAQ

    The FAQ sets out the proposed seed of about 3.5 million BAL in the treasury, 1.6 million in a Balancer Labs fundraise safe and 928,000 in a Labs team safe.

    CryptoSlate

  4. Update

    CryptoSlate reports the request and its effect on wind-down redemption

    The outlet said tokens granted before the proposed wind-down snapshot would mean the same treasury is divided among more BAL, and that the grant, technology rights and redemption terms still need separate decisions.

    CryptoSlate

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
CryptoSlate
Crypto media
Balancer fork’s 6 million BAL ask could cut holders’ redemption valueOriginal