Vitalik Buterin argues ETH should be valued as a store of value, not a fee-burning token
Vitalik Buterin said in an X thread on Nov 8 that ETH should be valued as a store of value rather than a fee-burning token; Arca's Jeff Dorman called the pitch misguided.
Why it matters
The argument walks back the 'ultrasound money' scarcity thesis that Ethereum backers used after the 2021 London upgrade, and it drew public pushback from an institutional investor, Arca's Jeff Dorman. Bitcoin.com News reported the store-of-value positioning places ETH in competition with Bitcoin for the same capital.
Where the sources disagree
Whether ETH works as a store of value
ETH's value comes from decentralization, censorship resistance, privacy and security, and it holds up as a store of value
Crypto.News, Bitcoin.com News, Unchained, Decrypt
A store of value is a claim to be a currency, and ETH has no use outside the Ethereum network itself
Unchained
Arca chief investment officer Jeff Dorman rejected Buterin's store-of-value case as resting on memetic social value, while Buterin and Ethlabs' Binji Pande defended it.
Key facts
Vitalik Buterin argued in an X post on November 8 that ETH should be valued primarily as a store of value rather than as a fee-burning token.
Reported by BTC-ECHO
Buterin said EIP-1559 should remain in place and that holders should not feel sad if fee burn stays below 10 percent of breakeven indefinitely.
10 %Reported by Crypto.News
Buterin said a burn of $1 billion a year at a 4 percent discount rate implies a $25 billion floor, and that this floor never really held for Ethereum because 2021 to 2023 burn came mostly from activity inside crypto.
25,000,000,000 USDReported by Unchained
Unchained reported Buterin cited a digital monkey sale that burned $180 million in fees in one day.
180,000,000 USDReported by Unchained
Crypto.News reported ETH traded near $2,240 when Buterin posted, and that Ethereum issues more tokens than it burns during periods of low network activity.
2,240 USDReported by Crypto.News
Decrypt reported Binji Pande, a founding member of Ethlabs, agreed with Buterin and called ETH a more future-proof store of value than Bitcoin, citing quantum and AI threats.
Reported by Decrypt
Unchained reported Arca chief investment officer Jeff Dorman called Buterin's pitch 'really misguided', saying a store of value is a claim to be a currency and ETH has no use outside the Ethereum network; DefiLlama showed about $6.2 million of Ethereum revenue in the last 30 days.
6,200,000 USDDisputed figureReported by Unchained
What happened
In a post on X on November 8, Vitalik Buterin argued that ETH should be valued primarily as a store of value rather than through the fees Ethereum burns, and he said the EIP-1559 fee mechanism should stay in place even if fee burn stays below 10 percent of breakeven indefinitely. He challenged the burn-based valuation math under which $1 billion burned annually at a 4 percent discount rate implies a $25 billion floor, saying most of the ETH burned from 2021 to 2023 came from activity inside crypto, and BTC-ECHO reported the burn has destroyed 21,100 ETH this year against 888,000 newly issued coins, a 2.4 percent emissions offset. Crypto.News reported ETH traded near $2,240 when Buterin posted. Decrypt reported Binji Pande, a founding member of Ethlabs, agreed and called ETH a more future-proof store of value than Bitcoin. Unchained reported Arca chief investment officer Jeff Dorman called the pitch 'really misguided', arguing that a store of value is a claim to be a currency and that ETH has no use outside the Ethereum network. Bitcoin.com News wrote that the shift from the 2021 'ultrasound money' narrative risks confusing Wall Street about what ETH represents and puts it where Bitcoin's store-of-value pitch is strongest.
How the story developed
- First report
First report by CryptoSlate
Vitalik is making private Ethereum payments without a crypto website
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by Altcoin Buzz
Vitalik Opens Devcon 8 in Mumbai With a Call for Trustworthy Technology
- Update
Crypto.News reports Buterin's X post backing ETH as a store of value over fee burns
- Official statement
Official statement from Bitcoin.com News
Ethereum Co-Founder Urges Embracing Store of Value Narrative
- Update
Bitcoin.com News, BTC-ECHO, Unchained, CryptoPotato and Decrypt corroborate the thread and add detail on the valuation math and the burn figures
Unchained quoted Buterin's line that fee burn below 10 percent of breakeven indefinitely is acceptable; BTC-ECHO reported 21,100 ETH burned year-to-date against 888,000 issued.
- Update
Arca CIO Jeff Dorman calls the store-of-value pitch 'really misguided' on Unchained
Dorman argued a store of value is a claim to be a currency and cited about $6 million of Ethereum revenue over 30 days via DefiLlama.
- Update
Bitcoin.com News reports the pitch moves ETH into Bitcoin's store-of-value territory for Wall Street capital
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 2 Nov 2026, 21:40 UTC: CryptoSlate — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 3 Nov 2026, 12:43 UTC: Altcoin Buzz — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
- 3 Nov 2026, 13:32 UTC: Crypto News (CryptoNews.net) — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
- 5 Nov 2026, 11:32 UTC: Crypto.News — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
- 8 Nov 2026, 16:51 UTC: U.Today — 5 independent sources, 10 reports
- 8 Nov 2026, 17:30 UTC: Crypto News Flash — 6 independent sources, 11 reports
- 9 Nov 2026, 08:30 UTC: Bitcoin.com News, official — 7 independent sources, 14 reports
- 9 Nov 2026, 08:31 UTC: BTC-ECHO — 8 independent sources, 15 reports
- 9 Nov 2026, 09:15 UTC: Unchained — 9 independent sources, 17 reports
- 9 Nov 2026, 16:44 UTC: CryptoPotato — 10 independent sources, 19 reports
- 9 Nov 2026, 17:14 UTC: Decrypt — 11 independent sources, 20 reports
- 16 Nov 2026, 07:58 UTC: CoinGape — 12 independent sources, 32 reports
Affected entities
Also mentioned: Optimism, United States, Riot Platforms, Shiba Inu, Chainlink, India, Solana