DevelopingResearch

Pump.fun preprint on 832,941 launches withdrawn after collector measurement flaw

Brave New Coin says a preprint reporting 0.198% of 832,941 pump.fun launches graduating within 24 hours was withdrawn in September after a collector flaw.

Why it matters

Graduation rate is the headline measure of how many pump.fun tokens succeed, and a collector that stops watching after a few minutes can undercount completions badly enough to distort any estimate built on it. With a single outlet and no preprint in evidence, how far the 0.198% figure departs from the true rate is still unknown.

Key facts

A preprint released in July analysed 832,941 token launches on pump.fun.

832,941Reported by Brave New Coin

The preprint reported that only 0.198% of the analysed launches graduated within 24 hours.

0.198 %Disputed figureReported by Brave New Coin

The preprint was withdrawn in September.

Reported by Brave New Coin

The 0.198% figure was repeated by exchange blogs, news sites and social media posts in many languages.

0.198 %Reported by Brave New Coin

On pump.fun a new token trades on a bonding curve and graduates to a regular trading pool once enough buyers arrive.

Reported by Brave New Coin

The collector recorded each token as graduated or as a timeout when it had not graduated within 24 hours.

24 hoursReported by Brave New Coin

The collector watched the stream of new launches instead of reading the chain's full history, so most tokens were watched closely only in the first few minutes of their life.

Reported by Brave New Coin

A graduated label recorded only completions seen while the collector was still watching.

Reported by Brave New Coin

What happened

Brave New Coin published an account of a preprint, released in July and withdrawn in September, that analysed 832,941 token launches on pump.fun and reported that 0.198% of them graduated within 24 hours. The outlet says the number was repeated by exchange blogs, news sites and social media posts in many languages before the withdrawal. On pump.fun a new token trades on a bonding curve, and once enough buyers arrive the curve completes and the token graduates to a regular trading pool, which is the event the preprint counted. The author states that the collector behind the 0.198% watched a stream of new launches rather than reading the chain's full history, so most tokens were tracked closely only in the first minutes of their life and a graduated label recorded only completions seen while the collector was still watching. No other outlet covers the withdrawal or the preprint, so the original figure rests on the account of one publication and has not been checked against the study itself.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by Brave New Coin

    What Auditing 832,941 Pump.fun Launches Taught Me About Memecoin “Success”

    Brave New Coin

  2. Update

    Brave New Coin describes a withdrawn pump.fun graduation study

    The outlet recounts a preprint of 832,941 launches, a 0.198% 24-hour graduation rate, a September withdrawal and the collector design flaw behind it.

    Brave New Coin

  3. Correction

    Collector flaw identified as the reason for the withdrawal

    The account says the collector followed new launches instead of full chain history, so a graduated label captured only completions seen while watching.

    Brave New Coin

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Brave New Coin
Crypto media
What Auditing 832,941 Pump.fun Launches Taught Me About Memecoin “Success”Original