Zcash's founding ceremony split key shards across six people, one revealed as Snowden
Crypto News recounts how six people ran Zcash's founding ceremony, each holding one key shard, before the hardware was destroyed.
Why it matters
The ceremony is the mechanism that stops someone minting counterfeit ZEC, so the account of who held the shards and whether the hardware was destroyed bears directly on the integrity of Zcash's supply. The reporting rests on one outlet, so the details have not been independently confirmed.
Key facts
Zcash uses zk-SNARKs, a zero-knowledge proof technique that shows a statement is true without revealing why it is true.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Early SNARK systems required a one-time setup producing a structured reference string, and the leftover secret randomness, called toxic waste, would let someone who rebuilt it forge proofs that still pass verification.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
For Zcash, a leaked master secret would let an attacker create unlimited counterfeit $ZEC without detection.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Six participants each produced one shard of the key set, in separate locations with separate hardware, using multi-party computation so no party saw the whole secret.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Zooko Wilcox recruited the group and the other participants were not told who else was taking part, so the setup fails only if every participant is compromised.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Crypto News names the participants as Zooko Wilcox, Peter Todd, Andrew Miller, Peter Van Valkenburgh of Coin Center and Derek Hinch.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
Derek Hinch used the pseudonym 'John Dobbertin', revealed in April 2022 to be Edward Snowden, a name chosen to honour the German cryptographer Hans Dobbertin.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
The machines used in the ceremony were destroyed after it took place.
Reported by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
What happened
Crypto News published an account of how Zcash was launched, describing a ceremony that split the coin's founding key material across six participants. The outlet says early zk-SNARK systems needed a one-time setup producing a 'structured reference string', and that the secret randomness left over, called 'toxic waste', would let anyone who rebuilt it forge proofs that pass verification and mint counterfeit ZEC. Six participants each produced one shard of the key set in a separate location with separate hardware, using multi-party computation so no single party saw the whole secret; Zooko Wilcox recruited the group and the others were not told who else was taking part, meaning the setup would fail only if every participant were compromised. Crypto News names Wilcox, Peter Todd, Andrew Miller, Peter Van Valkenburgh of Coin Center and Derek Hinch as the participants, and says Hinch used the pseudonym 'John Dobbertin', revealed in April 2022 to be Edward Snowden, chosen to honour the German cryptographer Hans Dobbertin. The piece says the machines were destroyed after the ceremony, though the account is cut off at that point. Everything here rests on a single outlet, so the identities, the recruitment method and the destruction of the hardware are unconfirmed by any second source.
How the story developed
- First report
First report by Crypto News (CryptoNews.net)
The Zcash “Ceremony”: The Strange Story of How the Coin Was Born
- Update
Crypto News publishes account of the Zcash founding ceremony
The outlet describes the multi-party ceremony, names the six participants and reports that one of them used the pseudonym John Dobbertin.
- Update
Ceremony participant identity revealed as Edward Snowden
Crypto News states that the participant using the pseudonym John Dobbertin was revealed in April 2022 to be Edward Snowden, without giving a date for the ceremony itself.
Affected entities
Also mentioned: Nasdaq
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crypto News (CryptoNews.net) Aggregator | The Zcash “Ceremony”: The Strange Story of How the Coin Was Born | Original |