Monero and Zcash Use Different Privacy Models Across Crypto Swaps
Monero makes transaction privacy mandatory, Zcash makes it selective, and crypto swap providers say privacy also depends on every network a transaction crosses.
Why it matters
These analyses do not report a market move, regulatory decision or new company action, so their direct market and regulatory significance is limited. For swap providers, the privacy boundary includes each network a transaction crosses, not just the starting coin's ledger.
Key facts
Brave New Coin's comparison of the projects' documentation says Monero makes transaction privacy mandatory, while Zcash restricts sender, receiver and amount privacy to shielded pools.
Reported by Brave New Coin
The July 2026 Ironwood upgrade added a new Zcash shielded pool and closed Orchard to new funds.
Reported by Brave New Coin
Neither Monero nor Zcash hides a user's IP address, transaction timing or where the coins came from beforehand.
Reported by Brave New Coin
SimpleSwap's H1 2026 Swap Report counted 91.8% of swaps as moving value between two networks.
91.8 %Reported by Crypto.News
What happened
Brave New Coin's comparison of project documentation says Monero makes transaction privacy mandatory, while Zcash restricts sender, receiver and amount privacy to its shielded pools. It reported that Zcash's July 2026 Ironwood upgrade added a new shielded pool and closed Orchard to new funds, while neither coin hides a user's IP address, timing or the coins' prior source. Crypto.News framed privacy as a property of the route after SimpleSwap and SecureShift marked five years of routing swaps for each other with six observations. SimpleSwap's H1 2026 Swap Report put cross-network swaps at 91.8%, legs outside the four largest chains at seven in ten, and stablecoins' sent-versus-received share up 9.2 percentage points. Neither account provides a measured rate for how often a swap changes what remains hidden, leaving that exposure unquantified.
How the story developed
- First report
First report by Brave New Coin
Monero and Zcash Privacy: What Each Coin Actually Hides
- Update
Zcash's Ironwood upgrade added a new shielded pool
The July 2026 upgrade also closed Orchard to new funds.
- Update
Brave New Coin published its Monero and Zcash privacy comparison
The explainer used the projects' documentation to distinguish mandatory transaction privacy from shielded-pool privacy.
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by Crypto.News
Privacy is a property of the route
- Update
Crypto.News published a route-based privacy analysis
The account covered five years of SimpleSwap and SecureShift swaps and reported SimpleSwap's H1 2026 data.
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 24 Sept 2026, 05:29 UTC: Brave New Coin — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 24 Sept 2026, 06:04 UTC: Crypto.News — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brave New Coin Crypto media | Monero and Zcash Privacy: What Each Coin Actually Hides | Original | |
| Crypto.News Crypto media | Privacy is a property of the route | Independent |