THORChain declined to block hacked Bitget funds, reviving debate over permissionless design
After Bitget was hacked, THORChain turned down a public request from Bitget CEO Gracy Chen to refuse service to attacker-linked addresses.
Why it matters
The refusal puts exchange operators and permissionless swap protocols on opposite sides of a question that comes up after every large theft, and it shows protocol operators can be pressured publicly by a victim. Because only one outlet has reported the dispute, the reaction from THORChain's validators and the wider DeFi community is not yet documented here.
Where the sources disagree
Total value of funds stolen in the Bitget hack
total given in the headline
Cointelegraph
slightly lower total given in the body text
Cointelegraph
The same Cointelegraph report states two different totals, one in its headline and a lower one in the opening of the body text.
Key facts
Cointelegraph reports that funds stolen in the Sept. 24 Bitget hack began moving across chains shortly after the theft, with some heading to cross-chain swap protocol THORChain.
Reported by Cointelegraph
Bitget CEO Gracy Chen publicly appealed to THORChain to refuse service to addresses linked to the attacker, telling the platform 'The industry is watching.'
Reported by Cointelegraph
Cointelegraph reports that THORChain refused that request.
Reported by Cointelegraph
Developer Boone Wheeler told Magazine that a truly permissionless protocol can do nothing when it encounters known stolen funds, and that a THORChain able to block specific stolen funds would not be permissionless.
Reported by Cointelegraph
Cointelegraph says THORChain previously did not stop the Bybit hackers from routing funds through the protocol.
Reported by Cointelegraph
Cointelegraph notes that THORChain validators voted in May to halt the chain after an automated system triggered when an attacker exploited a vulnerability and drained more than ten million dollars from a vault, which critics cite against the protocol's idealism.
Reported by Cointelegraph
Cointelegraph is the only outlet in this set reporting the dispute between Bitget and THORChain.
Reported by Cointelegraph
What happened
Cointelegraph reports that stolen funds from the Sept. 24 Bitget hack began moving across chains, with part of the total heading to THORChain, a cross-chain swap protocol. Bitget CEO Gracy Chen publicly asked THORChain to refuse service to addresses linked to the attacker, saying 'The industry is watching.' Cointelegraph reports that THORChain refused, which split commentators between those who hold protocols morally responsible for blocking stolen funds and those who treat permissionless design as untouchable. Developer Boone Wheeler told Magazine that a truly permissionless protocol can do nothing when it meets known stolen funds and that blocking them would make THORChain something else. Critics of that position point to May, when validators voted to halt the chain after an automated system responded to an attacker who exploited a vulnerability and drained a vault. Cointelegraph also notes that the same report gives one total in its headline and a slightly different one in its body, and the outlet is the only one in this set covering the dispute.
How the story developed
- Update
Bitget hacked and stolen funds begin moving across chains
Part of the stolen funds heads toward THORChain.
- First report
First report by Cointelegraph
Furious debate about THORChain vs NEAR shows idealism has limits
- Official statement
Gracy Chen asks THORChain to refuse service to attacker addresses
The Bitget CEO makes a public appeal, warning that 'The industry is watching.'
- Update
THORChain declines the request
Cointelegraph reports the refusal, which triggers a dispute over whether protocols owe a duty to block stolen funds.
- Update
Validators halt THORChain in May after a vault exploit
An automated system triggers after an attacker exploits a vulnerability; critics cite the halt as evidence the protocol can intervene.
- Official statement
Developer Boone Wheeler defends the permissionless position
Wheeler tells Magazine that a protocol able to block known stolen funds would not be permissionless.
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cointelegraph Crypto media | Furious debate about THORChain vs NEAR shows idealism has limits | Original |