Coin Metrics rebuilds Ethereum flow metrics, complicating exchange outflow backtests
Coin Metrics recomputed Ethereum Standard Flow Metrics from genesis using its latest data, so backtests of exchange outflow trading signals now face a data-vintage problem.
Why it matters
Research and trading systems that treat Ethereum exchange outflows as a signal face a choice between original and rebuilt data, and results can differ depending on which vintage the test used. Coin Metrics says the corrected history is available for backfilling, so existing backtests may need to be re-run. No return difference has been shown.
Key facts
Coin Metrics set out the change in a notice dated Oct. 1
Reported by CryptoSlate
Coin Metrics recomputed Ethereum Standard Flow Metrics from the network's first block as part of its Point-in-Time release
Reported by CryptoSlate
The rebuild covers all ETH Flow Metrics at daily and hourly frequencies, with corrected history available for backfilling
Reported by CryptoSlate
The rebuild used Coin Metrics' most up-to-date information, so revised history can include later wallet discoveries
Reported by CryptoSlate
Backtests that replay a trading rule need the data vintage available when each decision would have occurred
Reported by CryptoSlate
The notice contains no revision amounts and no ETH strategy comparison
Reported by CryptoSlate
No change in returns is established; measuring the trading effect requires paired data vintages, fixed rules and publication timing
Reported by CryptoSlate
What happened
Coin Metrics said in an Oct. 1 notice that it rebuilt Ethereum Standard Flow Metrics from the network's first block as part of its Point-in-Time release, using its most up-to-date information. CryptoSlate reported the change covers all ETH Flow Metrics at daily and hourly frequencies, and that corrected history is available for backfilling. The rebuilt series can include exchange wallet identifications made after the events they describe, which CryptoSlate said means a chart pulled today can show past flows using knowledge acquired later than a backtest had at the time. CryptoSlate said measuring any trading effect requires paired data vintages, fixed rules and publication timing, and that no change in returns has been established. The notice itself supplies no revision amounts and no ETH strategy comparison, so the size of any historical correction is unknown.
How the story developed
- First report
First report by CryptoSlate
Ethereum’s past outflow charts can change when more exchange wallets are identified
- Official statement
Coin Metrics issues notice on Ethereum flow metric rebuild
The Oct. 1 notice says Ethereum Standard Flow Metrics were recomputed from genesis with the most up-to-date information as part of the Point-in-Time release.
- Update
CryptoSlate reports the data-vintage problem for outflow backtests
CryptoSlate noted that charts pulled today can reflect wallet knowledge acquired after the periods they describe, and that no return change is established.
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| CryptoSlate Crypto media | Ethereum’s past outflow charts can change when more exchange wallets are identified | Original |