BitcoinBTC, coin
DevelopingProtocol update

Bitcoin Magazine Guest Post Says Fedimint Now Runs Three Independent Implementations

Bitcoin Magazine published a guest post from Fedi co-founder Obi Nwosu reporting that Fedimint developers ran one federation across three separate implementations at Ecash Hackday in Berlin.

Why it matters

Fedimint is a Bitcoin custody layer, and running one federation across independent codebases bears on the single-implementation risk that Bitcoin Magazine's author raised weeks earlier. Only one outlet reported it, in an opinion-labelled guest post rather than a Fedimint release or an independent confirmation.

Key facts

Cashu's thesimplekid built one of the three Fedimint implementations.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

Before the Berlin hackday, Fedimint had a single implementation of the protocol, which Nwosu described as a software monoculture below federations of humans and not secure enough.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

Matt Corallo expressed the critique as run the same software, suffer the same bugs.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

Nwosu said Fedimint developers responded to his earlier criticism by asking who builds the fourth implementation.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

The post states that a developer named Calle took the same principle and ran with it in his own direction.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

The account is a guest post by Obi Nwosu, co-founder of Fedi and Fedimint, labelled as expressing only his own opinions and not necessarily those of BTC Inc. or Bitcoin Magazine.

Reported by Bitcoin Magazine

What happened

A guest post by Obi Nwosu, co-founder of Fedi and Fedimint, published by Bitcoin Magazine reports that a single Fedimint federation ran across three independent implementations at Ecash Hackday in Berlin, with one implementation built by Cashu's thesimplekid. Nwosu writes that the earlier setup had only one implementation of the protocol below federations of users, which he called a software monoculture and described as not secure enough. He quotes Matt Corallo as stating the critique in succinct terms: run the same software, suffer the same bugs. Nwosu also says Fedimint developers asked who would build a fourth implementation. The same post mentions that another developer, Calle, took the principle in his own direction, but the evidence supplied cuts off before describing what Calle did. Only Bitcoin Magazine carried this account, and the piece is labelled a guest post whose views are those of the author and not necessarily those of BTC Inc., so the milestone rests on a single outlet's report.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by Bitcoin Magazine

    Ecash Ecosystem Rises to Challenge in the Defense of Decentralized Custody

    Bitcoin Magazine

  2. Update

    Nwosu argues Bitcoin's trust framing is the wrong question

    A few weeks before the hackday, Nwosu wrote that the Bitcoin ecosystem frames everything as trusted or trustless and urged people to ask how many independent things must fail before money is lost.

    Bitcoin Magazine

  3. Update

    Single-implementation Fedimint criticised as a software monoculture

    Nwosu said Fedimint had only one implementation of the protocol below federations of humans, which he called not secure enough, and said he was the first to say it.

    Bitcoin Magazine

  4. Update

    One federation runs across three implementations at Ecash Hackday in Berlin

    The Fedimint team got a single federation running across three separate codebases, with one implementation built by Cashu's thesimplekid.

    Bitcoin Magazine

  5. Update

    Developers asked who would build a fourth implementation

    Nwosu described the team's response to the monoculture critique as asking who builds the fourth implementation.

    Bitcoin Magazine

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Bitcoin Magazine
Crypto media
Ecash Ecosystem Rises to Challenge in the Defense of Decentralized CustodyOriginal