D.C. Circuit Affirms Sterlingov Conviction and Upholds Chainalysis Reactor Evidence
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit affirmed Roman Sterlingov's conviction and 150-month sentence for operating Bitcoin Fog, upholding the admission of Chainalysis Reactor blockchain analysis testimony.
Why it matters
The ruling establishes that proprietary blockchain analytics can meet federal evidentiary standards without source code disclosure, setting precedent for how courts evaluate digital forensic tools in cryptocurrency prosecutions.
Where the sources disagree
Number of Bitcoin addresses attributed to Bitcoin Fog by Reactor
more than 900,000 Bitcoin addresses attributed to the mixer service
Blockchain.News
matched four of five known Bitcoin Fog addresses; separate-case check covered 99.9% of a larger group
CryptoSlate
Chainalysis claims over 900,000 addresses attributed, while the court record cites matching four of five known addresses with 99.9% coverage of a larger group in a separate check
Key facts
The court upheld the admission of Chainalysis Reactor-based expert testimony
Reported by Blockchain.News
Sterlingov's challenge to obtain Reactor's source code was denied on materiality and preservation grounds
Reported by CryptoSlate
Expert testimony from FBI Specialist Luke Scholl and Chainalysis expert Elizabeth Bisbee supported Reactor's methodology at trial
Reported by Blockchain.News
Chainalysis published commentary on October 13, 2026 presenting the ruling as validation of Reactor
Reported by Blockchain.News
The district court found Reactor met the threshold for admissibility in 2024
Reported by Blockchain.News
What happened
On September 25, 2026, the D.C. Circuit affirmed Roman Sterlingov's convictions and 150-month sentence for operating the Bitcoin Fog mixing service. The court upheld the district court's decision to admit expert testimony based on Chainalysis's Reactor platform, rejecting Sterlingov's renewed challenge to its admissibility. Sterlingov's attempt to obtain Reactor's source code failed on materiality and preservation grounds, though counsel and qualified experts could inspect the software's heuristics. Chainalysis stated on October 13 that the appellate court relied on Reactor's clustering methodology, track record, and use by law enforcement and private-sector specialists. The company said Reactor attributed more than 900,000 Bitcoin addresses to Bitcoin Fog, while the court record noted Reactor matched four of five known Bitcoin Fog addresses with a separate-case check covering 99.9% of a larger address group.
How the story developed
- Resolution
D.C. Circuit affirms Sterlingov conviction and sentence
Appellate court upholds convictions and 150-month sentence for operating Bitcoin Fog
- Official statement
Chainalysis publishes commentary on ruling
Company presents appellate decision as validation of Reactor methodology
- First report
First report by Blockchain.News
D.C. Circuit Upholds Chainalysis Reactor Evidence in Sterlingov Case
- Official statement
District court finds Reactor admissible
U.S. District Court rules Reactor meets threshold for admissibility as evidence at trial
- Update
Blockchain.News reports on Chainalysis announcement
Coverage of Chainalysis statement regarding D.C. Circuit ruling
- Independent corroboration
Independently corroborated by CryptoSlate
Bitcoin Fog operator’s conviction upheld without Chainalysis disclosing source code
- Update
CryptoSlate publishes independent analysis
Detailed breakdown of court reasoning on wallet tracing evidence and source code disclosure
How coverage built up
Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.
- 14 Oct 2026, 15:10 UTC: Blockchain.News — 1 independent source, 1 reports
- 14 Oct 2026, 15:30 UTC: CryptoSlate — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
Affected entities
Original sources
| Publisher | Report | Role | Published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blockchain.News Crypto media | D.C. Circuit Upholds Chainalysis Reactor Evidence in Sterlingov Case | Original | |
| CryptoSlate Crypto media | Bitcoin Fog operator’s conviction upheld without Chainalysis disclosing source code | Independent |