CardanoADA, coin
DisputedGovernance

Cardano DReps reject Toto Finance's 22 million ADA treasury request for copper

Cardano delegated representatives rejected Toto Finance's bid to withdraw 22 million ADA from the treasury to buy physical copper, with opposition outweighing support by more than 140 to one.

Why it matters

The 22 million ADA stays in the treasury, and a fresh request would need the same 67% DRep approval, as Altcoin Buzz reported. Crypto.News calculated that the rejection preserved roughly 42.6 million ADA in remaining spending capacity under the current 500 million ADA withdrawal limit. Bitcoinist put the rejected request at approximately $5 million.

Where the sources disagree

Figures that do not reconcile

Found by comparing the numbers in the reports automatically. They are differences, not yet confirmed to be about the same thing.

reported value

14.72 million ADA

U.Today

20.02 million ADA

The Crypto Basic

U.Today reports 14.72 million ADA, The Crypto Basic reports 20.02 million ADA (26% apart).

size of the holdings

22 million ADA

Crypto.News

20.02 million ADA

Altcoin Buzz

Crypto.News reports 22 million ADA, Altcoin Buzz reports 20.02 million ADA (9% apart).

size of the holdings (cardano)

22 million ADA

U.Today

20.02 million ADA

Altcoin Buzz

U.Today reports 22 million ADA, Altcoin Buzz reports 20.02 million ADA (9% apart).

size of the holdings

22 million ADA

The Crypto Basic

20.02 million ADA

Altcoin Buzz

The Crypto Basic reports 22 million ADA, Altcoin Buzz reports 20.02 million ADA (9% apart).

Key facts

Toto Finance submitted a proposal on October 15 for a one-time treasury withdrawal of 22 million ADA to buy and tokenize physical copper as the Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve

22,000,000 ADADisputed figureReported by Crypto.News

The governance action expired on November 15, 2026 at 21:44 UTC with no funds released, in epoch 667 according to Altcoin Buzz

Reported by Crypto.News

DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA voted no against 20.02 million ADA in favor, per Cardano governance data including Cardanoscan

2,860,000,000 ADADisputed figureReported by Crypto.News

The proposal needed 67% of the active voting stake and received 0.51% when voting closed

0.51 %Reported by Crypto.News

126 DReps voted no, five voted yes and eight abstained on the on-chain record

126Reported by The Crypto Basic

None of the seven Constitutional Committee members approved the request; three voted against its constitutionality and four did not vote, per Crypto.News

Reported by Crypto.News

Toto Finance planned to spend 14.72 million ADA on copper, with the remainder for technology, operations and oversight, and DRep John MacPherson cited fees of up to about 3.4 million ADA

14,720,000 ADADisputed figureReported by Crypto.News

Bitcoinist described the rejected request as spending approximately $5 million from the treasury on physical copper

5,000,000 USDReported by Bitcoinist

What happened

Cardano delegated representatives rejected Toto Finance's request to withdraw 22 million ADA from the network treasury to buy and tokenize physical copper, with voting closing on November 15, 2026 at 21:44 UTC. Explicitly opposed stake outweighed explicit support by more than 140 to one: 2.86 billion ADA voted no against 20.02 million ADA in favor, and the proposal drew 0.51% support against a required 67% threshold. The Crypto Basic counted 126 DReps against, five in favor and eight abstaining, and reported an official no share of 99.49% once no-confidence and non-voting stake were included in the 3.93 billion ADA no side of the approval calculation. None of the seven Constitutional Committee members approved the request; Crypto.News reported three voted against its constitutionality and four did not vote. DRep John MacPherson wrote on X that he is not against real-world assets on Cardano but objected that the proposal asks the treasury 'to take on both the copper price and the ada price' and would let Toto collect 'up to about 3.4M ada in fees', while calling it more honest about its risks than most. Toto Finance, a US-based firm led by Monty Metzger, planned to spend 14.72 million ADA of the withdrawal on COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes, with the rest covering technology, operations and oversight.

How the story developed

  1. Resolution

    Voting closes with the proposal rejected

    Expired November 15, 2026 at 21:44 UTC with 2.86 billion ADA against and 20.02 million ADA in favor

    Crypto.News

  2. First report

    First report by Crypto.News

    Cardano holders reject 22M ADA treasury bid to buy physical copper

    Crypto.News

  3. Update

    Toto Finance submits the 22 million ADA copper reserve proposal

    Submitted October 15; needed 67% DRep approval plus Constitutional Committee sign-off

    Crypto.News

  4. Update

    U.Today corroborates and adds DRep John MacPherson's explanation

    MacPherson criticized copper and ADA price risk and cited up to about 3.4 million ADA in fees

    U.Today

  5. Update

    The Crypto Basic and Altcoin Buzz publish the full tally

    126 DReps against, five in favor, eight abstaining, and the 99.49% official no result

    The Crypto Basic

  6. Independent corroboration

    Independently corroborated by Altcoin Buzz

    Cardano DReps Reject Toto Finance's 22M ADA Copper Reserve

    Altcoin Buzz

  7. Update

    Bitcoinist frames the rejected bid at approximately $5 million

    Reports the request as a roughly $5 million treasury spend on physical copper

    Bitcoinist

How coverage built up

Independent sources over time, counted the way the consensus panel counts them: a republication of a wire story does not move the line.

16 Nov, 07:585 independent sources16 Nov, 20:28
  • 16 Nov 2026, 07:58 UTC: Crypto.News — 1 independent source, 1 reports
  • 16 Nov 2026, 11:27 UTC: U.Today — 2 independent sources, 2 reports
  • 16 Nov 2026, 15:32 UTC: The Crypto Basic — 3 independent sources, 3 reports
  • 16 Nov 2026, 15:57 UTC: Altcoin Buzz — 4 independent sources, 4 reports
  • 16 Nov 2026, 20:28 UTC: Bitcoinist — 5 independent sources, 5 reports

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Crypto.News
Crypto media
Cardano holders reject 22M ADA treasury bid to buy physical copperOriginal
Bitcoinist
Crypto media
Cardano Holders Reject $5M Investment as Treasury Proposal FailsIndependent
Altcoin Buzz
Crypto media
Cardano DReps Reject Toto Finance's 22M ADA Copper ReserveIndependent
U.Today
Crypto media
Cardano Holders Put Billions of ADA Coins to Block $5 Million Copper ReserveSyndicated
The Crypto Basic
Crypto media
Cardano Voters Reject 22,000,000 ADA Copper ReserveSyndicated