DevelopingLegal

US judge dismisses Burwick Law's LIBRA and M3M3 suit against Hayden Davis with prejudice

Protos reports a US judge threw out Burwick Law's LIBRA and M3M3 lawsuit against Hayden Davis and other defendants with prejudice, saying the allegations failed legal tests.

Why it matters

The with-prejudice dismissal closes a legal route for the LIBRA and M3M3 plaintiffs rather than resolving who was at fault, and Protos quotes a crypto law firm founder saying the ground was legal sufficiency, not memecoin legality. How far it affects other suits over the same tokens is not established by this single-source report.

Key facts

US Judge Jennifer Rochon dismissed Burwick Law's lawsuit over the LIBRA and M3M3 launches with prejudice, with findings filed on Tuesday.

Reported by Protos

Rochon denied plaintiffs Omar Hurlock and Anuj Mehta leave to file a second amended complaint, calling the attempt 'futile'.

Reported by Protos

The court granted three motions from the so-called 'Kelsier Defendants' — Hayden Davis, Kelsier Labs, Gideon Davis, Charles Thomas Davis and Benjamin Chow — and from intervenor plaintiff Dynamic Lab.

Reported by Protos

The defence motions argued that Burwick Law could not prove Meteora was a suable entity.

Reported by Protos

The defence motions argued that Burwick Law could not prove Benjamin Chow was fraudulent in his activities and could not establish personal New York jurisdiction over the Kelsier defendants.

Reported by Protos

The defence motions argued that Burwick Law could not establish a consistent pattern of racketeering in the six-month timeline of token launches.

Reported by Protos

The dismissed suit accused the defendants of a coordinated insider trading scheme involving the December 2024 M3M3 launch and LIBRA, the token Protos describes as publicly launched by Argentinian President Javier Milei.

Reported by Protos

What happened

Protos reported that US Judge Jennifer Rochon dismissed Burwick Law's lawsuit against Hayden Davis over the LIBRA and M3M3 token launches with prejudice, in findings filed on Tuesday. She denied plaintiffs Omar Hurlock and Anuj Mehta leave to file a second amended complaint, calling it 'futile', and granted three motions filed by the so-called 'Kelsier Defendants' — Davis, Kelsier Labs, Gideon Davis, Charles Thomas Davis and Benjamin Chow — plus intervenor plaintiff Dynamic Lab. According to that outlet, the motions argued that Burwick Law could not prove Meteora was a suable entity, could not prove Chow was fraudulent, could not establish personal New York jurisdiction over the Kelsier defendants, and could not establish a consistent pattern of racketeering across the six-month timeline of token launches. Ariel Giver, founder of a crypto law firm, told Protos the dismissal should not be read as meaning memecoins are legal, and that the plaintiffs 'sued the wrong thing, under the wrong statute, with the wrong facts'. The case had accused the defendants of a coordinated insider trading scheme covering the December 2024 M3M3 launch and LIBRA, which Protos describes as the token publicly launched by Argentinian President Javier Milei, and which the outlet says caused over $250 million in investor losses. Only one outlet covers the ruling in this evidence set, so the account of the judge's reasoning and the $250 million figure rest on that single report and are not independently confirmed here.

How the story developed

  1. First report

    First report by Protos

    Burwick Law loses LIBRA lawsuit against Hayden Davis

    Protos

  2. Update

    Judge Jennifer Rochon dismisses Burwick Law's LIBRA and M3M3 suit with prejudice

    Protos reported that Rochon's findings were filed on Tuesday, denying a second amended complaint and granting three defence motions.

    Protos

  3. Update

    Crypto law firm founder says dismissal is not a ruling that memecoins are legal

    Ariel Giver, quoted by Protos, said the plaintiffs 'sued the wrong thing, under the wrong statute, with the wrong facts'.

    Protos

Affected entities

Original sources

PublisherReportRolePublished
Protos
Crypto media
Burwick Law loses LIBRA lawsuit against Hayden DavisOriginal